We had an interesting experience yesterday on Fifth Avenue as we were walking to the Metropolitan Museum of Art. The stretch of "museum mile" near Central Park not only connects several museums but is notably home to a variety of street vendors who will gladly sell you cheap reproductions of famous paintings, photographs and magazine covers.
Here's the story.
We saw one vendor who sold a variety of parodies of the "Hope" poster featuring Barack Obama. Some were funny, so I took my phone to take a snap. The vendor got aggressive. "Hey, hey, hey! This is my work!" he yelled at us, protecting his $5 products with his arms.
Now, of course, I found this instantly ironic. I pointed to the reproduction of the "original" Hope design, the one made by Shepard Fairey during the 2008 U.S. election campaign. "You made this? You actually own the copyright and trademark on this image?" I asked.
Well, that made him a little, um, upset. "Get outta here!!" he screamed. We left, and couldn't help but laugh.
Let's review the case: the fellow was not only appropriating the design of someone else (and, as someone reminded me later, Fairey himself ran into trouble because he used a copyrighted photograph owned by someone else), but a host of copyrights, including the owners of characters such as Homer Simpson and Peter Griffin.
Moreover, it's not like the fellow had come up with something remotely original. Parodies of the Hope design are rampant, and you you can easily make one yourself on the internet, right here for instance.
The lesson for our son, apart from those involving intellectual property and fair use, moreso pointed to a particular type of vendor: the raging idiot.
Recent Comments