I believe I first heard Love Will Tear Us Apart in the fall of 1980, on CBC Radio's 90 Minutes with a Bullet, if memory serves, but I stand to be corrected. There weren't many avenues to hear a song like that in that pre-video, pre-web era. I was a teenager at the time, and was morbidly fascinated that Joy Division's singer, Ian Curtis, had killed himself just a month after the song came out. If the song might have seemed like a sneer of a retort to the sunniness of the Captain and Tenille, Curtis's death put it in another context. Curtis's young widow had the title of the song engraved into his headstone.
Over the years, the song has gutted me more than once, as my adult self understood and appreciated the song so much more.
Love Will Tear Us Apart has had a remarkable life of its own. It's now regarded as a classic, and likely will last for the ages. It's certainly been covered enough times, which is what this week's playlist is all about.
Damhnait Doyle: Love Will Tear Us Apart. The idea for this set comes from Dav's new album Lights Down Low, a colletion of covers. My first reaction on hearing this tune was, Why bother? It's similar enough to the Nouvelle Vague cover (see below) that I felt it was a bit of a retread. The cover, though, has grown on me, and I quite like the rest of the album, which Doyle put together with producer Danny Michel. (Any chance of a hometown concert soon, Dav?)
Nouvelle Vague: Love Will Tear Us Apart. The French hipsters opened their 2004 debut album - a set of covers with a bossa nova style of new wave songs (nouvelle vague loosely works as a translation of both, with a nod to French cinematic history - with this reworking of Joy Division, exchanging the thundering bassline with plucked guitars and chiming percussion.
Paul Young: Love Will Tear Us Apart. Paul Young was everywhere in 1983. No Parlez reinvented Marvin Gaye and other soul gems, but also made me (and I'm sure many others) look at Love Will Tear Us Apart differently. It was no longer a Joy Division recording, but a song.
Calexico: Love Will Tear Us Apart. My favourite of the lot. Available on a 2005 Starbucks compilation called Sweetheart, it's a streamlined rendition, but as rhythmic in its own right.
Hawksley Workman: Love Will Tear Us Apart. A B-side from about five years ago. Workman gives the song a dirge of a slowdown. Available through iTunes.
Vitamin String Quartet: Love Will Tear Us Apart. Speaking of iTunes ... I rummaged around the store, sampling a wide variety of covers. This one - from an album called the Gothic Wedding Collection - is part of a series of string quartet arrangements of modern songs, from Enjoy the Silence (Nouvelle Vague got there first, too, with a carnival treatment) to Orinoco Flow to - unlikely as it is for a wedding album - Please, Please, Please Let Me Get What I Want. I liked it enough to buy the works.
New Order: Love Will Tear Us Apart (iTunes Originals Version). I also found that New Order last fall did an iTunes Originals series, reworking some of their own material, as well as revisiting the main legacy from Joy Division (in part, I imagine, because of the Anton Corbijn film Control). A very energetic cover of their own work, down to the keyboards and bass.
Click on the link below to see other playlists.
Recent Comments